Search Dating Articles: Search  
Meet Someone New Dating, butterflies, romance... it all happens here.
I’m a
Seeking a
Age
to
Location
Find My Match   Advanced Search
GET STARTED
Create Profile Create Your
Personals Profile
Let the person you are looking for find you! Creating a profile is free, so get started now. Create a Profile  
DATING TIPS
You asked.... "Should I let him 'sow his oats'?"

Experts and readers answer our members' toughest dating and relationship questions

By Jeff Cohen, G.J. dePillis, and Sheila Ellison Updated: Apr 24, 2008
You Asked...
RATING THIS ARTICLE
Average (162 votes) stars Rate it: Sign in to rate!
"I have been seeing my boyfriend, Brian, for 10 months now. I am the first woman he has dated since his divorce, whereas I have been divorced for 10 years and have dated numerous men. We get along great and have a really good relationship. He is 45, I am 43. We are very much in love, or were. The problem is that Brian has been telling me he wants to have a taste of the single life now. He says he loves me and he wants to be with me, but he doesn't want any regrets. I know he cheated on his wife during their marriage, but the circumstances were very different than they are with us. I don't know whether I should continue seeing him, as I really do love him, or let him 'sow his oats' and hope he comes back to me.
 
"He was the one who pushed for the serious relationship very early on; now he is the one pulling away. We have been bickering lately, mainly because he has been stressed with work, plus our teenage children are very demanding on us for our time. How I should handle this?" -- Sherry W., 43, Columbus, Ohio
 
Jeff Cohen Answers
Sherry -- This is always a tough dilemma. Letting him "sow his oats" could either drive him away for good or make him realize what he's missing with you. The challenge is, you won't know the answer until he gives it a shot.
Rather than leaving it to chance, I always prefer controlling your own destiny. That means getting him to be honest. I'd recommend saying something like, "Look, we both know we have something special here. We also know that if you date other people it will change our dynamic forever. I need you to think long and hard about whether this need to pull away has to do with work and kids stress or a real desire to see other people.
“If it's about work/family issues, then we can work through this together and find a good balance.”
If it's about work/family issues, then we can work through this together and find a good balance. But if you're instead feeling there might be something better out there romantically for you, then I can't stop you. I can only say you need to make that decision with a clear head, understanding that our relationship as it stands today may not exist when the fun and games grow tiresome."
Jeff Cohen is the author of "Dating, Inc.," a new book that shows women a step-by-step plan for finding true love using the same skills that already make them successful at work.
G.J. dePillis Answers
Okay, Sherry! Let's do some serious troubleshooting.
1. Examine the SYMPTOMS:
  • Your children complain about the amount of time you spend with your mate.
  • Your mate and you have FON (Fights Over Nothing).
  • Your mate suggests you see other people, but does NOT suggest breaking up.
  • You are the first woman he has had a relationship with since his recent divorce.
2. Find the ROOT CAUSE: You reacted to Brian's invitation for commitment by giving him your entire heart, which means a relationship, which means fun! However, it also means accountability and responsibility, which is too similar to a marriage. He just got out of one!
“Right now, Brian wants the fun, carefree aspect of your relationship but is not ready for the responsibility.”
Right now, Brian wants the fun, carefree aspect of your relationship but is not ready for the responsibility. By seeing other people, he is simply searching for a less-demanding, less-FON environment. He wants you to be fun, the way you were when you first met.
3. Apply the RESOLUTION: Go to the softball-saturated Lou Berliner Park right near you in Columbus, Ohio. Scoop up some dirt with one hand. Squeeze your hand shut. What happens to that dust? It quickly slides out between your fingers with the focused determination of a batter sliding into home base. Now, scoop up the dirt again, this time leave your hand open and notice the mound of dirt that stays right there in the palm of your hand. That's how you need to treat Brian - open-handed...loose.
Develop a hobby that you do alone, or with your children, and/or with other adults. When you next chat with Brian, regale him with lighthearted stories about how much you enjoyed your hobby with others. Let him set the pace of how much time to spend together. Let him miss you.
G.J. dePillis' book "How to Troubleshoot Your Mate" shows how to apply principles from engineering, the second oldest profession, to create a more satisfying love relationship. Sign up for G.J.'s free newsletter at pure-force.com.
Sheila Ellison Answers
Sherry -- It is impossible to fully commit to a relationship when you have doubts. It sounds like Brian jumped into a serious relationship with you a bit too soon, having not dated anyone else after his divorce.
“Better to let him have some space to make sure he can commit to you with no regrets.”
Better to let him have some space to make sure he can commit to you with no regrets.
This would mean the "rules" of your current relationship would change. You would also have the space to date other people. Since you do love each other and have admitted that you want to be with each other, dating other people might cause some problems down the road if you don't set boundaries you can both live with. Examples of boundaries: not telling each other the details of your dating life, taking three to six months off and not seeing each other while you date others, going to dinner once a week to keep in touch, not having sex with each other while you date others, or not having sex with others while you date. Whatever works for the two of you.
Since he's the one who wants to date others, you will need to move forward in your life, setting your own goals and going after the life you want so that you aren't sitting around waiting for him to finish his dating stage. The goal is that neither of you build resentment towards the other. Otherwise, a long-term relationship will not work.
What's your question?
If you're a Yahoo! Personals member with an active profile, you're eligible to submit a question. We'll select challenging questions for experts and readers to answer. Submit your question here
Now it's your turn to answer this question. Yahoo! Personals reserves the right to delete any off-topic comments from readers.
Leave a comment COMMENTS50 COMMENTS
1-10 of 50 First | < Prev | Next > | Last
A Yahoo! Contributor
He&#39;s a cheater- He proved that with his wife. He wants to keep you in his pocket because he &quot;loves&quot; you, yet he wants extra candy on the side too. The feeling of being able to pick up a chick and having her want him sexually. I suggest moving on and finding a real man that honestly loves you, not just the game of catch and release. Be careful though, if you tell him to take a hike, he will profess his love for you and only you, then take his extras on the side... just like with the wife. A lot of women want to be &quot;the one&quot;, but when you find &quot;that one&quot; he wont want, or even ask, to be with anyone but YOU!
A Yahoo! Contributor
The last piece of advice was ok, ignore the other two. Let me tell you something, from a guys point of view, if he wants to sow his royal oates, he&#39;s going to do it with or without your permission. I&#39;m surprised if even told you about it, most men just do it. I&#39;m going to tell you how to play him (or you&#39;ll find out real quickly if he really loves you or not). Agree to this. Tell him considering the recent circumstances, that you agree this will be good to strengthen your relationship in the long run. Right now, he&#39;s going to be confused because he&#39;s not going to expect that. However, make sure he knows this is a mutual thing, that you&#39;ll be dating as well and you must date as well. Make sure he knows you&#39;re going out with people, don&#39;t return his phone calls right away, if he asks where you were you had plans, if he pushes, tell him it&#39;s not his business, or you can tell him you were a date if you really want to make him nuts. You&#39;ll probably be closing more deals than him! If he really loves you,he&#39;ll put the kabosh on the &quot;seeing other people&quot;. If he doesn&#39;t care about your other dating, well, he just doesn&#39;t care about you as much as you think nor does he love you, at least now you know.
No Photo
You have to learn to work through the ups and downs of marriage and commitements. Men and women both get bored after a while. You have to find the true joy of intimacy. I do not mean in the sack, anyone can do that. Find time to spend with each other and examine why you guys were attracted to one another in the first place. If it was all sexual then you are probably out of luck. If he wants to run around because he has gotten bored then he learned nothing in the first divorce.
A Yahoo! Contributor
PLAYING GAMES IS NOT THE WAY TO HANDLE THIS ISSSUE.
A Yahoo! Contributor
Don&#39;t go deaf and blind to the facts. Once a cheat, always a cheat. You are setting yourself up in the crosshairs for a major heartache if you stick with him. If he&#39;s not satisfied with you now, he never will be. Things may be &#39;different&#39; with you than with his ex, but, as that saying goes, the more things change, the more they stay the same. Find someone else to fall in love with.
A Yahoo! Contributor
You&#39;re 43 years old and you&#39;re still letting men treat you this way?! Um...hello?! I&#39;m half your age and if my husband gave me that tired old line I&#39;d say, &quot;There&#39;s the door, buddy!&quot; I felt this way with my last boyfriend when I met my husband and now I&quot;m married! Chances are, there&#39;s something going on in your relationship that he&#39;s unhappy with and wants out since it&#39;s not getting fixed. If you want to try to make things work, I think you should seek counseling to get to the root of what&#39;s wrong. If not, let him go and find someone who wants to be with you always.
A Yahoo! Contributor
As a man who&#39;s been married once, I would say let him do whatever he needs to do. If he&#39;s made it clear that he wants to play around in the single life again then there is no reason to hold him from that. This is honestly a situation in which you will just have to let me go and hope that he will come back to you. But, in the meantime, make sure you aren&#39;t sitting around waiting for him
A Yahoo! Contributor
Sherry, You need to really decide what YOU are looking for. If you want casual dating in your life right now and you are comfortable with the prospect of dating other people (and him dating others), then let him have his space. I disagree with others urging you to rub in his face that you too will be seeing others. He will see this as you seeking to contain him. Again, if you are truly comfortable with a casual relationship with him (and others), then maintain a casual relationship with him. Who you choose to see besides him is then only your business. On the other hand, if you are truly looking for a serious, exclusive relationship, then you need to tell him that. Don&#39;t get mad or upset, just be calm and tell him that he should not feel bad about wanting a more open relationship, and that is his right, but that you have different goals.
No Photo
I agree with Mike, Adam and even Ishmael ....... I think this whole &quot;mid life crisis&quot; is a mans excuse to do things they know are wrong. If a man says he needs to sow his oats, its way of saying he wants to cheat and make excuses for it. But, that is just my opinion!
A Yahoo! Contributor
I suppose it may be wrong to make judgment here but believe me ...Once a cheater always a cheater !!!!
1-10 of 50 First | < Prev | Next > | Last
imageLEAVE A COMMENT

You must sign in to leave a comment

Dating Articles  |  Success Stories  |  Browse By Location  |  5-Star Safety  |  Gift Subscription  |  Site Map
Copyright © 2008 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.  |  Legal  |  Jobs  |  Help
NOTICE: We collect personal information on this site. To learn more about how we use your information, see our Privacy Policy.